Tim Priebe

Email Newsletter Provider Comparison

email-newsletter-roundup-flatLast week, we mentioned some factors to look at when comparing email newsletter providers. So which email providers should you look at, and how do they compare?

Here are just a few of the more popular, reputable email newsletter platforms. Obviously, you’ll still need to take a look and see how well they fit with you and your organization.

(Just looking for a price comparison? Scroll down past all the write-ups below.)

MailChimp

Screen-Shot-2013-06-28-at-3.06.22-PM-190x190MailChimp has a reputation for being one of the simpler to use services out there. They also have one of the better free accounts. If you have less than 2,000 subscribers, you can send up to 12,000 emails a month for free. Many of our clients here at T&S never pay for MailChimp, and just continue to use their free account.

The company has a light-hearted approach toward business. Their mascot, Freddie, can be seen throughout the backend cracking jokes. While that is a feature you can disable, it shows you their business philosophy, which we can relate to here at T&S.


Constant Contact

Screen-Shot-2013-06-28-at-3.06.03-PM-190x190Constant Contactis one of the more popular email marketing companies. This is due in no small part to the fact that by default, their logo is displayed in the footer of every email their users send out.

They’ve begun purchasing other companies and offering more than just email marketing services. While some feel this dilutes their primary service, others appreciate the one-stop shop.

They let you try their plan free for 60 days with up to 100 contacts.


AWeber

Screen-Shot-2013-06-28-at-3.05.52-PM-190x190AWeber is the provider we used before switching over to MailChimp. They always had fantastic customer service, and their capabilities were good as well.

Ultimately, we switched because MailChimp’s had a cleaner, simpler interface. Many of our clients choose to manage their email newsletters themselves, so that was important.

They don’t seem to have a free trial, but do offer  up to 500 subscribers and unlimited emails for just $1 for the first month, with a 30-day money back guarantee.


iContact

Screen-Shot-2013-06-28-at-3.05.39-PM-190x190
iContact provides both email marketing and social media marketing. Just like Constant Contact, this can be either an advantage or a disadvantage, depending on your point of view.

iContact does have a 30 day free trial. They claim it has no strings attached. I’m not sure if that means no limitations for that 30 days or not.


Emma
Screen-Shot-2013-06-28-at-3.05.24-PM-190x190

Emma is one of the smaller companies that made our list. They place an emphasis on clean, simple, and stylish email marketing. Both the front end and the back end of their website reflect that. They offer a free 30 day trial account.


Mad Mimi

Screen-Shot-2013-06-28-at-3.03.18-PM-190x190

Mad Mimi is another smaller provider. One of our clients speaks very highly of the company, and has had great experiences with their customer service.

Their free plan includes up to 2,500 contacts and you can send 2,500 emails. Since that’s slightly more than MailChimp allows, they’ve likely attracted some of the attention simply through the free plan.


Price Comparison

Here’s a break-down of some popular email services. I’ve simplified it a bit so you can actually compare apples to apples.

SubscribersMailChimpConstant ContactAWeberiContactEmmaMad Mimi
500$10.00$15.00$19.00$14.00na$10.00
1000$15.00$30.00$29.00$19.00$30.00$12.00
2500$30.00$30.00$29.00$29.00$45.00$16.00
5000$50.00$50.00$49.00$47.00$70.00$27.00
10000$75.00$75.00$69.00$74.00$85.00$42.00

One provider above, iContact, actually offers a plan for just 250 subscribers. All providers also offer plans over 10,000, but most have you contact them for a quote.

Comments

    • That’s definitely another option. Personally, I’ve found the interfaces those companies provide to not be as easy to use as some of these options, but that’s definitely a matter of opinion.

  1. Thanks for the list Tim, another service getting a lot of attention is sendinblue.com for its prices based on number of emails sent per month

  2. Interesting list Tim. Some providers are definitely new to me. I currently use mailchimp but can never get my newsletters to arrive in the google primary tab, whereas I notice aweber more frequently lands there.

    Got any ideas about this. It would definitely be interested to hear them!

    • Thanks, Elle! Glad you found the list useful. As I understand it, the more subscribers that drag your emails manually into the Primary tab in Gmail, the more often it will show up there for others. If you have a team of VIP subscribers set up in MailChimp, you might see if they’re willing to help you with this. You can share MailChimp’s official instructions with them: http://bit.ly/1cep4Nu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

seo-superhero

Learn how you can improve SEO

Frustrated that your business or nonprofit doesn’t rank highly in Google searches?

Baffled by confusing online advice on Search Engine Optimization?

Become an SEO Superhero, our free ebook, gives you a brief, practical overview of Search Engine Optimization with proven tips on how to increase your organization’s ranking.

You have Successfully Subscribed!